Health Language Blog

A Banking Analogy that Explains Semantic Interoperability

Posted on 01/16/15


Without semantic interoperability among disparate healthcare IT systems, sharing data in a useful way is impossible.

While a doctor knows that dropsy describes the same illness as congestive heart failure, a computer typically can’t make that type of distinction. Semantic interoperability, however, creates a common vocabulary that paves the way for accurate and reliable communication among computers.

This fluent machine-to-machine communication depends on the ability of different HIT systems to map different terms to shared semantics, or meaning. Semantic interoperability is viewed as critical for a number of healthcare initiatives including  quality improvement programs, population health management and data warehousing. It also plays a pivotal role in emerging healthcare organizations and models including health information exchanges, Accountable Care Organizations and Patient Centered Medical Homes.

While it’s easy to see why semantic interoperability is important, grasping its essence isn’t quite as simple. An analogy from the banking industry helps explain the concept. But first, here is a summary of how the Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society (HIMSS) defines the different levels of data exchange, including semantic interoperability.

The HIMSS Definition

HIMSS has published an interoperability definition that describes ascending tiers of interoperability. The lowest tier -- called foundational interoperability -- permits data exchanged from one HIT system to another, but does not require the receiving system to interpret the data.

Building upon the base tier, structural interoperability “defines the structure or format of data exchange,” according to HIMSS. The Health Level 7 (HL7) series of standards, for example, provides guidance on how messages should be structured.

Semantic interoperability, meanwhile, represents the highest level of interoperability in the HIMSS definition. Semantic interoperability deals with the content of the messages exchanged among HIT systems, not just the messaging format.

“Semantic interoperability takes advantage of both the structuring of the data exchange and the codification of the data including vocabulary so that the receiving information technology systems can interpret the data,” HIMSS noted.

The ATM Parallel

Automated Teller Machines, long a staple of consumer banking, provide a useful analogy for shedding light on the HIMSS definition and semantic interoperability. When a customer swipes his or her magnetic stripe card or smart card, the ATM terminal reaches out to a host processor that, in turn, links the terminal to the ATM interbank networks. This basic level of communication parallels the exchange of data between two HIT systems on a network.

The ATM terminal, host processor and interbank networks provide the baseline infrastructure for conducting a banking transaction. The next step is to create a common container for carrying the data to be exchanged.  At the structural interoperability level, banks use standards such ISO 8583 to define the message format used in ATM transactions. ISO 8583 plays a role similar to HL7 in the healthcare sector. In both cases, messages are exchanged across a network through an established and mutually accepted protocol.

Finally, ATMs used in currency conversion represent the highest level of data exchange, semantic interoperability. Interbank networks such as PLUS and Cirrus make it possible for U.S. residents to obtain funds from an ATM machine belonging to a foreign bank. The ATM system processes the international transaction, automatically converting a cardholder’s funds from U.S. dollars to the local currency. In effect, the content of the message flowing through the ATM network is translated so it becomes relevant to both the cardholder’s U.S.-based bank and the foreign bank. Semantic interoperability transcends language and currency differences.  

What seems like a seamless transaction for consumers is an orchestration by a number of different institutions relying on a communication network and agreed upon standards to achieve interoperability.  In healthcare, we strive for this same goal.

The Search For Meaning

Are different terminologies and classification systems blocking your healthcare initiatives? What are your most challenging disconnects? Leave your comments below.

enterprise terminology management

Topics: semantic interoperability

About the Author

Brian Diaz is the Director of Integrated Solutions with Health Language, part of Wolters Kluwer Health. When not working, Brian is soaking up the Colorado experience with his family but still cheers on the Golden Gophers.